A Tale Dark and Grimm – Adam Gidwitz (2010)
avatar

Another fairy tale remake! This book claims to tell “the real story” of Hansel and Gretel. It starts with Faithful Johannes (supposedly about Hansel and Gretel’s parents), then uses that as motivation for why Hansel and Gretel ended up eating the witch’s house. After that, we skip through other random fairy tales following Hansel and Gretel, who are sometimes inserted into the story in odd ways. Most of the fairy tales, like Brother and Sister, don’t really follow the original story much, but it’s all tied together pretty nicely by Hansel and Gretel wandering around looking for trustworthy adults and getting into scrapes. The last couple of chapters seem to be original adventures for H&G, to wrap up the story.

Throughout the book, the author stops the story to talk to the readers. Ever read the Princess Bride? It’s just like that, kinda cute. He’s constantly warning the reader to make sure that there are no kids around because the story is about to get scary, and it kind of is. There are beheadings, kids get chopped up, Hansel eventually visits Hell and sees sinners getting tortured, etc.

This book wasn’t bad, but I don’t think I’d read it again.

 

This entry was posted in Children's, Fantasy and tagged , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to A Tale Dark and Grimm – Adam Gidwitz (2010)

  1. shelleybean1 says:

    Hmm, would this be a good one for Sammy? You mentioned it’s in his age range.

    And here I was just wondering which fairy tale I could remake that hadn’t been too overdone, and what’s the only thing to pop into my head? Hansel & Gretel. Ah well.

    • kelley says:

      hmmm, I think no. it just wasn’t good enough for me to recommend, really.

      aww, Hansel and Gretel was never a favorite fairy tale of mine. One of the (overdone) princess ones might be better.

Leave a Reply